< Back to insights hub

Article

Commercial Disputes Weekly Issue 302 17 November 2026

Some key court guidance on interpretation of Building Safety Act 2022 provisions, finance broking contracts, termination provisions and types of guarantees are considered in this edition of Commercial Disputes Weekly.

"An entity does not become liable merely because it is a developer or is legally associated with one."Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government v Urban Splash Ltd [2026] UKFTT 01426 (PC), 5 November 2026

BUILDING SAFETY

The First-Tier Tribunal has handed down a detailed decision, making remediation contribution orders (“RCOs”) in relation to seven high-rise residential buildings in Manchester. Remedial works costing more than £60m had been completed but largely paid for by the government’s Building Safety Fund. The Tribunal considered that it was appropriate to make RCOs against the developer and four associated companies, who were jointly and severally liable for £46.5m. In reaching this decision, the Tribunal gave useful guidance on the meaning of ‘relevant defect’ and ‘building safety risk’ under the Building Safety Act 2022, with both ‘defect’ and ‘risk’ being broadly interpreted. It also considered how control can be exerted in the context of which companies are associated. The Tribunal concluded that the respondents were not liable to repay the full amount spent from the government fund in recognition of its shared responsibility for the circumstances that produced the building safety crisis. The Tribunal acknowledged that the developer had helped post-Grenfell investigations into the safety of the buildings but noted that they had not accepted responsibility for the resulting remediation. The fact that it was insolvent did not outweigh the case for requiring the developer not the taxpayer to bear the remediation costs.

Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government v Urban Splash Ltd [2026] UKFTT 01426 (PC), 5 November 2026

FINANCING – MINING

The Court of Appeal has upheld a decision that a finance broker was entitled to commission even though it had not introduced the investor to the company. Blyvoor, a mining company, engaged two finance brokers on non-exclusive terms to assist with obtaining funding to bring a disused gold mine back into production. Legacy Hill introduced the investor but Exotix was able to provide modelling and back-office functions, as well as connections with the Industrial Development Corporation of South Africa, a state-owned body that would provide part of the funding. The requirement was for Exotix to help place the investments and have a “real world effect on securing the funding”. Exotix had satisfied that test by providing valuable technical and analytical support.

Alphier Capital Two LLP v Blyvoor Gold Capital (Pty) Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 1432, 9 November 2026

CONTRACT TERMINATION

Two parties entered into 25 foreign exchange forward contracts, but the relationship was terminated by Ballinger after it asserted that the trades fell outside the defined category. The court held that Ballinger had been entitled to terminate the trades pursuant to clause 4.6 of the contract, where it came to a rational decision (as per Braganza v BP Shipping [2015] UKSC 1) that the trades would be outside its permitted authorisation. However, the contract also provided that Ballinger was obliged to ‘close out’ the trade by booking opposite trades at market rates. As Ballinger did not do this, it was obliged to compensate the other party, Aamanya, for the fair market value of its positions.

Aamanya AG v Ballinger & Co Ltd [2026] EWHC 2905 (Comm), 11 November 2026

BANKRUPTCY – GUARANTEES

The Court of Appeal has allowed an appeal against a decision that a claim under a guarantee was a claim which could form the basis of a bankruptcy petition. The court concluded that the relevant guarantee was a ‘see to it’ guarantee in which the guarantor was promising that the company would pay. If it does not, the guarantor is in breach of that obligation and liable in damages. This contrasts with a conditional obligation to pay if the company does not, which gives rise to a debt obligation. A debt for a liquidated sum was required to form the basis of a bankruptcy petition under section 267 of the Insolvency Act 1986 and there was no such debt here.

Matthews v BSN (SW) Property Ltd [2026] EWCA Civ 1442, 11 November 2026

 

< Back to insights hub

< Back to insights hub